When Joan Crawford Was Fifth Fiddle – Tramp, Tramp, Tramp (1926)


There was a time when both Joan Crawford and Frank Capra were working for the success of the very same man. He was none other than Harry Langdon, one of the most popular comedians of the 1920s. Just like many others, he started his career under the supervision of Mack Sennett and by 1926 he was confident enough to settle his own production company. Many say this was the beginning of his decline. It may be so, but one thing is for sure: it was also the beginning of Joan Crawford’s rise.

The first comedy that the Harry Langdon Corporation produced was “Tramp, Tramp, Tramp”, which was also the very first feature film Harry Langdon has ever appeared in. The movie’s title refers to the lines of a popular Civil War song: “Tramp, tramp, tramp, the boys are marching, cheer up comrades they will come”. The lyrics are adequate enough, since the story features Harry, the son of a poor shoemaker, who participates in a huge walking competition all across the American continent in the hope of the high prize and the love of the shoe manufacturer’s daughter he’s been admiring for long.

Even though Langdon’s faithful team of writers (would-be director Frank Capra was also among them) and director friend, Harry Edwards, were glad to stay by his side, he needed a new leading lady very urgently. The story of his upcoming movie didn’t require someone with huge acting experience – all they needed was a girl who looked well in front of the movie camera.


Harry Langdon, the forgotten clown

Those days Joan Crawford had high hopes of becoming a renown actress. Nonetheless her career began only the previous year and she had no opportunity yet to shine her acting abilities in her movies. She was given bit parts in low quality films at MGM and only her relationships with most of the men in leading positions kept her going. Since she was not missed at all, MGM was glad to loan her to Harry Langdon’s company.

Joan was forced to accept the role but she was deeply dissatisfied with it. She was hoping for a breakthrough but instead she had to play an unimportant romantic interest to Langdon with very little to do, something she thought was not much better than her roles at MGM.

“Tramp, Tramp, Tramp” was a wistful comedy but the picture belonged to Harry Langdon. I was playing not second fiddle, not third fiddle, but more like fifth fiddle to Harry’s comic stunts. 

It is true that her character is not a very accurately worked out one. In the movie her posters advertising shoes spread all over America and these posters probably show up more often than she does personally. She mainly serves as a subject for a couple of gags and strangely enough she also falls for Harry’s character at the first possible moment – which is quite hard to understand considering his foolish behavior and the huge social gap between them.


Harry with “his dream girl” – one of Joan’s posters

Even though Joan felt bad about her role, she is reported to have had a good time on the set. Frank Capra recalled later that during her only big scene with Harry she was laughing so hard that she was asked to turn backwards the camera, so her laughing fit wouldn’t be that noticeable. In spite of  all that, years later she remembered Harry as a deeply unhappy person.

There seemed to be a deep dark hole in him, a hole he could never seem to climb out of. Working with him was a very remote, detached experience. He put on the required gestures and expressions, but as soon as the camera stopped rolling, he retreated into his own private self. He was self-destructive, got too big a head, thought he knew it all.

Her bitter words were surely influenced by Frank Capra’s long-lasting debate with Langdon which began after the end of their cooperation and which resulted in many ugly gossips that kept circulating about Harry long after his career had ended.


Filmed from behind

Crawford also profited from her brief association with a different make-up unit. Since the emphasis was on her appearance, not her acting,  she was made up much more attractively than for her previous movies. The cameramen tried hard to photograph her the best possible way, and as a result her looks and moves seem especially gentle.

When I got back to MGM I had picked up some makeup tricks that I clued in the MGM people on. I was made up better for the camera from then on, I feel.


Photographed flatteringly

Period reviewers were only moderately enthusiastic. Many of them pointed out the movie’s similarities to Chaplin’s Gold Rush which was released the previous year and they didn’t praise Crawford, either, dismissing her as a “nice leading lady with little to do.” However from today’s point of view “Tramp, Tramp, Tramp” is a perfectly innocent comedy with Harry Langdon’s antics in the limelight and everything else at the periphery.


This is my contribution to “The Joan Crawford Blogathon” hosted by Crystal from In The Good Old Days Of Classic HollywoodCheck out her blog for other entries!

My sources: joancrawfordbest& joancrawfordma & travsd & ny times & Lawrence J. Quirk and William Schoell: Joan Crawford: An Essential Biography

6 thoughts on “When Joan Crawford Was Fifth Fiddle – Tramp, Tramp, Tramp (1926)

  1. Your research about Joan Crawford’s participation was fascinating. I have this film on my list to see and it was wonderful to learn about Harry Langdon and Crawford’s experience on the set.

    It’s great to hear that though she played fifth fiddle, she at least got something out of the film – lighting and makeup techniques – and had fun!


    • Thank you very much for your kind words! I was very happy to find so much material on a movie that’s not a very important one! I think it must be because of Joan’s later fame.
      Have you seen any Langdon movies before? If you did, I think you’ll enjoy this one, too. If you haven’t you’ll soon get over the first shock (just as I did) and enjoy the second half of it 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      • I have only seen Harry Langdon in one short film, so I’m extremely curious. I’ve been wanting to catch up on silent comedians beyond Chaplin, Keaton, and Lloyd and I thought Langdon should be next, but I didn’t know much about him. I’ll remember what you said and keep an open mind and enjoy! And it will be fun to see Joan Crawford. 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I can see why Joan C. may not have been entirely pleased with her role, judging by the clip you posted, because you just can’t compete with Harry Langdon!

    Thanks for sharing your research re: Joan’s thoughts on this film, and Harry, and technical know-how. It’s a great read!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s