A Silent Movie Ice Cream Battle – A Pair of Tights (1929)


If there was such a genre as “ice cream comedy”, I think A Pair of Tights would be an award-winning piece.  With its delightful cast and gentle story it’s so amusing that it makes you laugh again and again. This movie certainly proves that in the golden age of silents a single gesture could speak louder and be funnier than a hundred words today.

I can hardly imagine that any movie has ever used ice cream as a prop in a cleverer way than A Pair of Tights. Mind you, they won’t use it properly; instead of some gentle licking, ice cream here becomes a dangerous weapon and a treasure to fight for – and to get hold of a couple of cones soon becomes the central motive of the characters. Of course all this is executed in the marvelous silent way when everything was still conveyed through body language or title cards.

By the second half of the 1920s, which is often called the golden age of the silent cinema, visual gags had been turned into an art form. Loads of fascinating comedies, such as A Pair of Tights, were produced in this flourishing era which was suddenly brought to an end by the appearance of the talkies. Though the first sound film, The Jazz Singer, was released in 1927 it wasn’t until the end of the decade that major studios decided to close down their silent film departments forever. 1929 was the last year when silent movies were still widely in circulation.


Hal Roach, photographed in 1920

A Pair of Tights was one of the last silents produced by Hal Roach, too. Roach was the owner of a huge studio making popular comedies and he soon became the competitor of Mack Sennett’s Keystone farces. He employed silent movie legends like Harold Lloyd, Laurel & Hardy and Charley Chase and was constantly experimenting with new ideas. In an attempt to create a female Laurel & Hardy duo, he teamed up Anita Garvin and Marion Byron for a couple of films in 1928-29. A Pair of Tights was part of this fugitive series.


Anita Garvin and Marion Byron in front of the ice cream parlor set

This time the girls are dating Edgar Kennedy and Stuart Erwin who are the “pair of tights” of the title which refers to their tightwad-like behavior. It’s true enough that Edgar doesn’t want to invite the ladies out for dinner; he offers to buy them ice cream instead so that they’ll lose their appetite. Yet in a silent comedy it’s not as easy to buy an ice cream as one might think. Trouble ensues when a furious policeman doesn’t let the boys park in front of the ice cream parlor while the girls find themselves engaged in fighting with a family living above the shop.


“A pair of tights” – Edgar Kennedy and Stuart Erwin

You might be familiar with this lovely short film if you’ve seen Robert Youngson’s compilation of silent movies, When Comedy Was King. The following snippet was featured in that documentary, with music and narration added and slightly edited, but if you’re interested you can also find the (allegedly) whole film on YouTube. Take some ice cream from the fridge and enjoy!

This is my eclassic-movie-ice-cream-social-harold-and-bebentry for The Classic Movie Ice Cream Social, hosted by Movies Silently. If you’d like to check out all the other posts, you just have to click here.

My sources: laurelandhardy.org; comedydissertation; lordheath.comwikipedia

14 thoughts on “A Silent Movie Ice Cream Battle – A Pair of Tights (1929)

    • Thanks for hosting, it was great fun! I’m glad you liked my review, I haven’t been familiar with Anita before, but I loved her character, too. Miss Byron was extremely talented, as well! It’s a shame so many wonderful comedies and actresses are hidden away!


    • I adore Chaplin’s movies and I also like Keaton, but you’re absouletly right that lots of others are not popular enough. For instance, I’ve recently discovered Charley Chase, he starred in some marvellous comedies, and I haven’t even heard of him before!

      Liked by 1 person

  1. What a great entry for the blogathon! I look forward to watching it as part of my on-going attempt to expand my knowledge of silent film. The phrase ‘a pair of tights’ is really interesting too, I’d never heard it used in that context.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s